The murder case that shocked the city of Perugia. The trial and the conviction of Amanda Knox for the murder of English student Meredith Kercher in Perugia set off a whirlwind of controversy in the American press. Justified or unjustified? Is a partisan national media inevitable in such high-profile cases?

Sabina Castelfranco CBS
Barbie Nadeau Newsweek, author of the book Angel Face: the real story of student killer Amanda Knox
Massimo Mapelli La7
Andrea Vogt seattlepi.com